Originally Posted by Sea Ray
Obviously we want to keep as many of our good players as possible but for the sake of discussion, who's more valuable? Michael Johnson or Carlos Dunlap? I'd argue it's Dunlap. Sure he does take plays off but he's also a playmaker and you can give no higher compliment to any NFL player. When Dunlap makes plays, it's turnovers or drive stoppers.
Good question because you know they will not resign both of them; one at most. Johnson had a better year than Dunlap has ever had (though he's had an extra year), and Dunlap's nagging injuries and taking some plays off worry me some, but I'd still go with Dunlap.