Re: Hall of Fame worthy? ....
Considering how often I hear people argue about a guy's peak years and dominating during a series of years, I thought there'd be at least a little debate about Carpenter. I obviously voted no because I put more stock in the career numbers than I do their peak value. Oh well...so much for that one. :O)
Pitching and defense...anything else is gravy. Mmmm...gravy.