Re: Should Bronson Arroyo make the Reds Hall of Fame?
Other than Scott Proctor, who I am not famaliar with who had -1.5 WAR in 40IP in 2011, Bronson Arroyo was the worst WAR pitcher in the majors in 2011 with a negative 1.3 WAR. CJ Wilson had 6+ WAR that year.
In 2012, both pitching 200+ IP, Arroyo and Wilson each had a WAR of 2.5. Baseball is such an interesting game. And as I mentioned earlier, Arroyo is one of the most interesting pitchers in said game.