Originally Posted by SweetLou1990
Coming off of their last minor league year, and going into 2011 for Mes and 2013 for Hamilton, Mes had a WAR of -0.2 and Billy Hamilton had a WAR of 1.0 (at the major league level. I'lltry to find some prospect ratings for each, WAR isn't fair prob when comparing these 2 positions.
Billy Hamilton can't have a WAR of anything. He has never played in the Majors. Catching WAR is incomplete and well known that it doesn't calculate their full defense.
Billy Hamilton, BA 2013 Rank was 20.
Devin Mesoraco, BA 2012 Rank was 16.