Originally Posted by SaboMVP
Because nobody is humoring that Dustin's good. So, like I've said for the fifth time, it comes down to him being good or bad. Why are you not reading what is plainly written?
You're not a logician.
Tim Tebow = Bad
Dustin Ackley = Bad
Tim Tebow = Hated
Dustin Ackley = Not Hated
. . There is something different in these situations OTHER THAN TEBOW BEING BAD. So it plainly (VERY plainly) doesn't come down to just him being bad. It must be the accompanying media attention then, which is basically not his fault. Or it must be something else. And you don't think it's something else apparently.
Sorry for selectively quoting. And I still urge you to stop using the word fallacy. For the love of God.