Originally Posted by Benihana
Don't forget Votto either. At this time, Winker is probably on par with what Votto was as a prospect (which was less than Bruce).
As good as Winker has been, Gelalich has been just as bad: .691 OPS through almost 300 plate appearances in Rookie and A ball for a sandwich round big college corner outfielder? That's pretty bad.
I know plenty of us were confused by his pick that high and he hasn't performed much to show otherwise. The plate discipline is MUCH better this year, so at least it is a step in the right direction.