Originally Posted by George Anderson
IMO Ashburn doesn't belong. Doby I think is in for his negro league achievents as well as his MLB achievements.
Again, IMO McGriff and his 497 HR's just aren't enough. If he had an MVP or a couple years where he was close in voting along with a reputation or some hardware showing he could play defense then yes he would be worthy of the HOF.
You mean a gold glove like Palmeiro won when he played only 20 or so games on the field? That would have given him some credit? Really? Wow