Re: Reds Grades so far...
Very surprised you guys are so down on Cozart. I would have gone around B+. He has been an average shortstop offensively and exceptional in the field. What did we expect from him? It's not his fault he bats 2nd.
I also don't think anybody should be giving Leake or Cingrani less than an A. These guys have broken out in a way nobody could have expected.
I'm not willing to give Broxton a pass just due to injury. He was a liability when healthy and I had high expectations for him after last year. Could probably make the exact same case against Hanigan, but it's hard to quantify if he's still making up for it defensively.
Everyone else, I pretty much agree with consensus.