Originally Posted by RedsfaninMT
A= Leake, Parra
A- = Choo
B = Phillips, Bruce, Chapman, Parch, Arroyo, Hoover, Simon, Cingrani, Ondrusek
B- = Paul, Robinson,
C+ = Izturis, Votto, Lecure
C- = Bailey, Mesoraco, Hannahan, Latos
D= Cozart, Heisey, Cueto, Marshall, Broxton
As I look at it, the only players who deserve above a "C" are those performing better than expected. Votto is performing as I expected. Many (too many) are doing far worse than I expected. Perhaps unfairly, I graded on an expectation of a healthy season.
I had high hopes and expectations of a 100 win season, obviously naively so, but not many are dong better than I thought they would.
I will give Ludwick an incomplete.