Originally Posted by Razor Shines
Really? As a joke I was trying to think of an opposite of this list and Pettitte was the first guy I thought of.
He's had a strong career but I'd hardly say he's widely underrated.
I don't know that underrated is the right word for Pettitte; it's more like unheralded. Here's a guy that's largely played his entire career for the Yankees, which would otherwise bring him a ton of praise; yet, you really don't hear much about him, despite the fact he has excellent career numbers. I think there's one clear reason for that: he's an admitted juicer.