Originally Posted by Rojo
I think Winker a tad overrated. I like him, even a lot. But I'm not over-the-moon about a slugging leftfielder in A ball.
Do you (and the others who liked this post) believe he is overrated because of his defensive position? I agree that he isn't an ultra-elite prospect like Stephenson because of this, but I can't think of a better #2 prospect in the Reds' system. All the guy does is hit and I think he will be able to play a pretty average defensive leftfield in the majors, especially when he is young.