Originally Posted by REDREAD
Yes, hands down (at least IMO). He was #1 for me before the season started, even ahead of Wagner. Wagner #2, and Encarcion #3.
I'm with Redread - if Pena were included he'd be #1. Then I'd have Encarnacion, Claussen, Wagner.
I believe Claussen has a higher ceiling and is a starting pitcher, Wagner only comes out ahead if he becomes a lights out closer (and I'm much less confident in this than I was last year)