Originally Posted by Redsfaithful
Peyton Manning > Tom Brady
Donovan McNabb > Peyton Manning
Just my opinion.
Manning and McNabb are close. All things being equal (and that's the problem with Manning, he has a TERRIBLE defense wwhere Brady and McNabb have great Ds), I'll take Manning. I think in the long run, Roesthliberger will be better than any of them. And Carson Palmer will be at least part of the conversation.