Originally Posted by Mutaman
Let me see if I understand this - You're arguing that Manning can win the big game because this year he beat Denver at home and last year he beat KC
on the Road? And that Brady has a weakness because he only led his team to the Super Bowl 3 out of the last four years, not four in a row? Or that one time in his 9-0 streak Bledsoe came in in relief? Ok you convinced me, I'm wrong. I conceed, your arguements are just too powerful.
No, I'm noting that your arguments are hanging by the most tenuous of threads and are illogical at best.
You credit Brady with 9 "wins" regardless of circumstance, venue, or playing time but you have now denigrated two Colts wins that your own logic says belong to Peyton Manning because it doesn't fit your premise (ie. that Manning can't win "big games" because you say so).
In order to say that, you're attempting to tell us that not all playoff games are "big games". Of course, they're all "big games" for Brady (even those he didn't play well in or play much of) in your world, but none are "big games" for Manning. Hogwash.
One doesn't have to put up a "powerful" argument in pointing out how inconsistent you've been this entire thread. All they need to do is read the posts.