Originally Posted by Matt700wlw
And you can't fully judge the offseason until you see how things play out
Speculate, Yes...judge, no.
I don't judge decisions based on results. I judge them based on their merit (ie. the probability of said decision working out).
Anything else is pure hindsight.
Hitting on a blackjack hand of 18 while the dealer has a 6 showing isn't a good decision even if you flop a 3.
If you've seen a player do that and hit 21, you sure don't say to yourself, "Wow. Was that SMART!". You say, "Wow. Was that dumb. Lucky, but dumb!"