It's no wonder the projections are so bad; look at the players' ages! Claussen is 9, Williams is 7, and little Davey Weathers is only 3 years old!
Then you get to the position players and you find out that the Reds just gave a new contract to a 231-year-old backup catcher! And I won't even mention Old Man Denorfia.
But seriously folks, while two or three of these guys may do better than projected, I don't think it's any secret that the Reds cannot win with this staff.