Originally Posted by cincyinco
Satchel Paige people... Satchel Paige..
He is so near the top of my list. For a guy to have been that good past the age of 40 is rather remarkable.
I would also go with Koufax, after he matured.
I would also go with the professor, Greg Maddox.
Clemens would get a huge nod.
And finally to round out the rotation, The Big Train. Sure, he was dead ball - but he dominated. Domination is domination, no matter what the era.