Let's not be silly. Lohse is certainly worth giving up a first round pick (especially the Reds' late-first round pick) if the contract makes sense. 2 years $20-25 million would make sense for Lohse. He would be the best #3 starter in baseball, but would be considered our #5. We would have a top-3 (in MLB) rotation and maybe the best bullpen in baseball. Signing Lohse would be fantastic.