You guys don't see Holliday every day as I do. If you did, you would see that most of his big hits come when they are not needed. I just wince when he comes to bat in a game situation. I can honestly say that I would rather see Descalso or Kosma up there!
Not to mention how much of the team salery he is gobbling up. The guy was making more $ than Pujols (when he was Pujols) for god's sake! He's making more than Yadi who is far and away the more valuable player.
W/O looking it up, I'm guessing that he leads the team in only 2 departments: Strikeouts and GIDP. He can't hit .300 anymore or hit 30 HRs. His defense is the worst on the team. You take him. Give me Luddy.