Actually you are the one being a thread cop.
Regardless of the fact that everyone disagrees with PP, he offered an opinion (and the mentally ill comment was not meant as fact... he was suggesting that if he truly is a Reds fan that his behaviour every time the Reds started winning appeared to be much less gleeful then when the Reds started losing).
Suggesting PP isn't entitled to an opinion (when he has made it clear he is just guessing and not stating facts).... well, that is being a condescending thread cop.