Personally, I think they are correct. The two no-hitters attest to his ceiling but then he seems to mail it in.
I'm thinking that Homer didn't grow up last year; he's still a bone-headed 'thrower'.
If he's not willing to sign a long term contract before the trading deadline ('cause I think he will at some point in his career become a 'quality pitcher') I'd trade him for any big right-handed bat I could get.
JMO.
Rem