Reds Grades so far...

[nate]

Team hitting: B
The Reds are 4th in runs scored and wOBA.

Team starting pitching: A-
All defense independent pitching metrics show the Reds as 2nd except tERA which puts them 6th. This could easily be a B+ or maybe B but the fact that they have the lowest BB/9 and are 5th in HR/9 nudges them into "A" territory to me.

Team relief pitching: B-
This could easily have been a C+. While they lead the league in K/9, they're decidedly bottom third in BB/9.

Team fielding: B
Pretty good. UZR has them at 5th and further describes them as excellent converting plays "in range" to outs. Where they falter is balls hit out of zone where they're last. However, these are all opportunity stats so there's likely some noise in there.

[Falls City Beer]

A: Choo, Votto, Leake
B: Arroyo, Bruce, Phillips, Chapman, Hoover, Latos, Frazier, Cingrani
C: Cozart, Paul, Ondrusek, Simon, Parra, Bailey
D: Hanigan, Mesoraco, Broxton, Robinson

[mdccclxix]

Votto B+
Phillips B+
Cozart C-
Frazier B-
Bruce A-
Choo B+
Paul B
Heisey C (injury)
Robinson B
Hanigan C-(injury)
Mesoraco C
Hannahan C
Itzturis B

Arroyo B+
Leake A
Latos A-
Cueto C (injury)
Bailey B+

Chapman B+
Parra A-
Broxton C (injury)
Hoover C
Simon B
Cingrani A
LeCure B

[Kc61]

A: Votto and Leake.
A-: Latos, Choo and Chapman.
B+: Bruce, Arroyo, Lecure, Phillips.
B: Bailey, Simon, Cingrani.
B-: Frazier.
C+: Hoover.
C: Parra, Cozart, Ondrusek.
C-: Broxton, Mesoraco, Partch, Heisey, Robinson, Hannahan.
D+: Hanigan, Izturis.

Note: This is for the full season so far, some of these guys have gotten better or worse more recently. Cueto and Marshall incomplete.