I live in Indy, and your probably referring to the Colts Grille, fantastic food at a great price. I know we may have the Pirates AAA affiliate, but the Indy Indians @ Victory Field offers great baseball at great prices, watched McCutchen hit many a home run out of The Vic. Hot Box Pizza downtown is absolutely fabulous also The Ram Restraunt and Microbrewey is great.
Also check out The Indianapolis Museum of Art, some great things there.
I saw Adam Dunn hit 2 HR in the AAA All Star game when he was there. One of the my favorite sports memories ever.