Turn Off Ads?
Page 1 of 4 1234 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 60

Thread: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

  1. #1
    8.3 Posts Abv Replacement BluegrassRedleg's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    South of Cincinnati
    Posts
    1,829

    What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Carlos Gomez No. 1. Andrelton Simmons No. 7. Starling Marte No. 8.

    WTMcF?

    Shirley (sic) you can't be serious, WAR.
    Rounding third and heading for home...

  2. Turn Off Ads?
  3. #2
    Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    735

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Quote Originally Posted by BluegrassRedleg View Post
    Carlos Gomez No. 1. Andrelton Simmons No. 7. Starling Marte No. 8.

    WTMcF?

    Shirley (sic) you can't be serious, WAR.
    WAR is an absurd stat.
    The same story has to be told about the defensive metrics which are included in WAR.

  4. #3
    We Need Our Myths reds1869's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Overlooking GABP
    Posts
    4,400

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Fangraphs has the following 2013 NL leaders: McCutchen, Gomez, Votto, CarGo, Goldschmidt. Baseball Reference has Gomez, McCutchen, Wright, Votto and Goldschmidt. Seems pretty fair to me on both counts. Why do you have a problem with any of the three you mention? Simmons may seem absurd but he is a wizard with the glove and better offensively than many at his position.

  5. #4
    Five Tool Fool jojo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Posts
    18,024

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    What are you to make of NL WAR? Some of your biases and erroneous preconceived notions about player valuation have been exposed?
    "This isnít stats vs scouts - this is stats and scouts working together, building an organization that blends the best of both worlds. This is the blueprint for how a baseball organization should be run. And, whether the baseball men of the 20th century like it or not, this is where baseball is going."---Dave Cameron, U.S.S. Mariner

  6. Likes:

    HokieRed (08-10-2013), RedEye (08-10-2013)

  7. #5
    Five Tool Fool jojo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Posts
    18,024

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Quote Originally Posted by BluegrassRedleg View Post
    Carlos Gomez No. 1. Andrelton Simmons No. 7. Starling Marte No. 8.

    WTMcF?

    Shirley (sic) you can't be serious, WAR.
    Just as a public service announcement for those with low post counts, trolling and masked profanity are both against board rules.
    "This isnít stats vs scouts - this is stats and scouts working together, building an organization that blends the best of both worlds. This is the blueprint for how a baseball organization should be run. And, whether the baseball men of the 20th century like it or not, this is where baseball is going."---Dave Cameron, U.S.S. Mariner

  8. #6
    Member
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Posts
    766

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Wow, you're pretty smug. You act like that with people in real life?

  9. Likes:

    Brutus (08-10-2013), DocRed (08-10-2013), Fil3232 (08-10-2013), jimbo (08-11-2013), junkhead (08-10-2013), Larkin Fan (08-10-2013), New York Red (08-10-2013), Norm Chortleton (08-12-2013), OnBaseMachine (08-10-2013), RANDY IN INDY (08-10-2013), Red in Chicago (08-10-2013), RedsfaninMT (08-10-2013), westofyou (08-10-2013)

  10. #7
    Five Tool Fool jojo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Posts
    18,024

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Quote Originally Posted by NeilHamburger View Post
    Wow, you're pretty smug. You act like that with people in real life?
    I was shocked by the OP too.
    "This isnít stats vs scouts - this is stats and scouts working together, building an organization that blends the best of both worlds. This is the blueprint for how a baseball organization should be run. And, whether the baseball men of the 20th century like it or not, this is where baseball is going."---Dave Cameron, U.S.S. Mariner

  11. #8
    Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    735

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Quote Originally Posted by reds1869 View Post
    Fangraphs has the following 2013 NL leaders: McCutchen, Gomez, Votto, CarGo, Goldschmidt. Baseball Reference has Gomez, McCutchen, Wright, Votto and Goldschmidt. Seems pretty fair to me on both counts. Why do you have a problem with any of the three you mention? Simmons may seem absurd but he is a wizard with the glove and better offensively than many at his position.
    WAR is not only undependable due to the inaccuracy of defensive and base-running stats but also gives too much weight to the defense.

    Just look at Simmons' offensive stats.

    Simmons: .243 .286 .364 .650

    However fantastic his defensive skill may be, it's just absurd.

  12. Likes:

    Always Red (08-10-2013), mth123 (08-10-2013), RedlegJake (08-10-2013)

  13. #9
    Five Tool Fool jojo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Posts
    18,024

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Quote Originally Posted by junkhead View Post
    WAR is not only undependable due to the inaccuracy of defensive and base-running stats but also gives too much weight to the defense.

    Just look at Simmons' offensive stats.

    Simmons: .243 .286 .364 .650

    However fantastic his defensive skill may be, it's just absurd.
    These things have been discussed ad naseum and the stated concerns have been demonstrated to not be valid reasons to reject the metric multiple times. Read the archives, they are loaded with great discussion on these issues.
    Last edited by jojo; 08-10-2013 at 09:36 AM.
    "This isnít stats vs scouts - this is stats and scouts working together, building an organization that blends the best of both worlds. This is the blueprint for how a baseball organization should be run. And, whether the baseball men of the 20th century like it or not, this is where baseball is going."---Dave Cameron, U.S.S. Mariner

  14. Likes:

    RedEye (08-10-2013)

  15. #10
    We Need Our Myths reds1869's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Overlooking GABP
    Posts
    4,400

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Quote Originally Posted by junkhead View Post
    WAR is not only undependable due to the inaccuracy of defensive and base-running stats but also gives too much weight to the defense.

    Just look at Simmons' offensive stats.

    Simmons: .243 .286 .364 .650

    However fantastic his defensive skill may be, it's just absurd.
    Those numbers place him in the top half of shortstops offensively, and a lot of those other players have much lesser defense. I'm not saying WAR is the greatest stat on Earth because I believe it has flaws. But Simmons is an extremely valuable player that provides a massive upgrade over a readily available replacement at his position.

  16. #11
    Stat Wanker Hodiernus RedsManRick's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    Chicago, IL
    Posts
    15,754

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Defense counts. Really, really good defense up the middle counts for a lot.

    While defensive stats might be less reliable than offensive ones, I'm really tired of having them discounted simply because they disagree with out gut instincts of what they should be. For example, people still treat defensive stats like they're a measure of talent that should be extremely consistent year-to-year instead of as performance with a healthy range of variability.

    (yes, I understand people's doubt comes in part due to how systems measure defensive performance and I don't want to debate this yet again)
    Last edited by RedsManRick; 08-10-2013 at 09:42 AM.
    Games are won on run differential -- scoring more than your opponent. Runs are runs, scored or prevented they all count the same. Worry about scoring more and allowing fewer, not which positions contribute to which side of the equation or how "consistent" you are at your current level of performance.

  17. Likes:

    jojo (08-10-2013), RedEye (08-10-2013), reds1869 (08-10-2013)

  18. #12
    Moderator Plus Plus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Location
    Indianapolis, IN
    Posts
    1,449

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    For the record, ESPN is using baseball-reference's WAR calculation, which, if I remember correctly, has been pretty consistently discounted for using poor fielding metrics in its calculation. Using Fangraphs' WAR leaderboard, I don't see Andrelton Simmons on the front page (Trout is #1 largely due to being 7 runs better on the bases; he is more than 2 wins better than Chris Davis, who has similar defense and wRC), and there aren't really any head-scratchers on the list.

    And also, doesn't WAR carry more weight as a career-cumulative statistic than a season statistic because of the nature of defensive stats needing to settle?

    But the real problem with WAR is case-study analysis that can leave even an educated fan scratching their head, such as this:

    Who would you rather have had as your shortstop last year -- Derek Jeter (the All-Star Game starter and future Hall of Famer) or the Mariners' Brendan Ryan (who hit .194 with a .555 OPS)? Yes, this is a trick question. Because while any sane fan will pick Jeter (even with his ankle in a cast) over Ryan, baseball-reference gave Ryan a WAR of 3.3 last season and Jeter a WAR of 2.1, probably because Ryan is the superior fielder. FanGraphs' spread is just the opposite: Jeter at 3.2 and Ryan at 1.7.
    http://espn.go.com/mlb/story/_/id/89...placement-stat

    The article here (which isn't super compelling as a whole, but brings up a couple good points about using WAR as a be-all-end-all stat) has a couple other less compelling examples than this as well, such as Ricky Nolasco's 2009 season where he had a 5.06 ERA and a WAR over 4 (disclaimer- I looked up Nolasco's statistics and don't think this is a great example in this article; the season was actually a good one except for, well, actual results).

    From the same article:

    As I wrote at the beginning, WAR can be a valuable measure. The problem is when it is used as the DEFINITIVE measure. Such as, "Mike Trout had a 10.7 WAR and Miguel Cabrera had a 6.9 WAR, so anyone who thinks Cabrera deserved to be the American League MVP should be strip-searched, tied to an anthill and forced to rely on dial-up for his Internet connection for the remainder of his pathetic life."

    Look, all stats have their limitations. If a player has a .329 batting average, that probably means he's pretty good. But for an accurate measure of the player, we need more information. How many extra-base hits does he have? How many times does he walk? How many stolen bases? How many runs, how many RBIs? How many double plays has he hit into? The same is true for a player with 40 home runs. Does he have a .300 average to go with them, or a .230 average? Does he strike out a lot? How often does he walk?

    The same approach should apply to WAR. We need to look at many stats to assess players, and one of them should be WAR. But it shouldn't be the only stat we look at or cite.
    Quote Originally Posted by westofyou View Post
    Thus his team was punished

    Long live punishment

  19. Likes:

    BlackPete Ibold (08-10-2013), thorn (08-10-2013)

  20. #13
    Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    735

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Quote Originally Posted by reds1869 View Post
    Those numbers place him in the top half of shortstops offensively, and a lot of those other players have much lesser defense. I'm not saying WAR is the greatest stat on Earth because I believe it has flaws. But Simmons is an extremely valuable player that provides a massive upgrade over a readily available replacement at his position.
    Simmons' WAR is 8th among all of position players in NL, not among all of shortstops.
    Is he 8th most valuable player in entire NL? I don't think so.

  21. #14
    A Dude in the Bushes RedTeamGo!'s Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    North Canton, OH
    Posts
    1,767

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Did you read the post before explaining that is on baseball-reference and not fangraphs?

  22. #15
    Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Posts
    735

    Re: What am I to make of some NL WAR leaders?

    Quote Originally Posted by RedTeamGo! View Post
    Did you read the post before explaining that is on baseball-reference and not fangraphs?
    Of course, I have read it.
    Why? Do you think that fangraphs' WAR is more accurate than baseball-reference' WAR?

    According to Fangraphs, Frazier(2.6) has a higher WAR than Bruce(2.3).
    How can you explain this?

  23. Likes:

    Blitz Dorsey (08-10-2013)


Turn Off Ads?

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Board Moderators may, at their discretion and judgment, delete and/or edit any messages that violate any of the following guidelines: 1. Explicit references to alleged illegal or unlawful acts. 2. Graphic sexual descriptions. 3. Racial or ethnic slurs. 4. Use of edgy language (including masked profanity). 5. Direct personal attacks, flames, fights, trolling, baiting, name-calling, general nuisance, excessive player criticism or anything along those lines. 6. Posting spam. 7. Each person may have only one user account. It is fine to be critical here - that's what this board is for. But let's not beat a subject or a player to death, please.

Thank you, and most importantly, enjoy yourselves!


RedsZone.com is a privately owned website and is not affiliated with the Cincinnati Reds or Major League Baseball


Contact us: Boss | GIK | BCubb2003 | dabvu2498 | Gallen5862 | LexRedsFan | Plus Plus | RedlegJake | redsfan1995 | The Operator | Tommyjohn25