I dunno about this one. He has a 6.373 rc27 which is good in this offense/pitching environment, and is outstanding considering he did absolutely nothing but make outs in the month of April. He plays multiple positions competently. This is really the first year he's gotten props despite being quite good the two previous years, tearing up the minors before that, and getting zero respect from most prospect mavens.
Jay Bruce is much more of an outmaker than this guy (5.444 rc27), and I'd but him on the overrated list way before Craig.