Phillips gone by mid December?

[ac084c]

Again you are wanting to go by one stat. I am saying that you look at a number of stats when reviewing a pitcher. ERA, W/L, WHIP and so on. I put the value of W/L up there as just as important as others. You don't. However again how many non 300 winners are there in the HOF? How many winners of the CY Young didn't have outstanding W/L records?

Valuing dudes based on former CYA wins.... Brian Sabean - is that you?

[bullseye]

So you think by adding a better player by ANY stretch of the imagination is a downgrade?


Here. Go to the big board and tell them that Stubbs is more valuablke thab Choo because they finished 3rd with Choo and see what feedback you get.

Stubbs was horrible. The Reds won despite of him. Without Choo last season, the Reds would have never made it to the wildcard. The bottom half of the lineup let us down. When we had Stubbs stinking it up, they hit down there. Huge difference between Stubbs and Choo.