I am totally opposed to 'selling' at this point. How many years can the Reds afford to keep this starting pitcher corp together? I really doubt whether we have Latos, Cueto, Bailey, Leake, and Simon for the long haul. Stephenson and Cingrani have potential, and that is good. However, one could argue that Joey, Ludwick, Shumaker, and BP are on the downward side of their careers. Frazier and Cozart are 28 and at their peak, and perhaps Bruce, Hamilton, and Mesoraco are young enough to get better.
The problem with throwing in the towel is that this could well be the closest we are to the top of the division for the next few years. I wouldn't give away the farm, but I sure wouldn't sell either.