I would do it without hesitation. I would do it for Seager and either one of the other two. If you could add Broxton and get all three, that would be unbelievable. It is true that Cueto cannot be replaced in 2015. There is no guarantee that he will be a Red in 2016 anyway. If he is, at what price? The prospects of a 5/100+ deal scares me. Moreover, it's not like the minors are without pitching. IMO, a trade like this would make the Reds contenders for the next five or six years.