Is my thinking off base here? Don't get me wrong, I love everything Tucker brings to the Reds, but I see everyone talking about the high return the Marlins are likely getting for Realmuto - plus many of the top contending teams need a catcher that does it all.
Why not trade Barnhart? Wouldn't the result of his trade lift the Reds skills better than holding on to him? Dodgers, Mets, Yankees, RedSox and more would be interested. Do you see a match that makes a great trade?