Good god, this 3-way deal absolutely reeks for the Reds.
Kevin Jarvis!?!? No thanks.
Dunn is no where near a decent 1st baseman, that is obvious from watching him in person play 1st.
Jr is not going to play first, nor should he.
WMP was not good in the OF last year. I've never seen a MLB player take all the indirect routes to get to the ball as he does. He does not read the ball off the bat well at all. His speed helps him make up for his initial mental mistakes.
IMO, Smitherman is not ready for the majors. He is definitely not withering on the vine.