Who should I drop??

[Red Leader]

My pitching staff:

SP Freddy Garcia
SP Mike Mussina
SP Jamie Moyer
SP Joel Pineiro
SP Adam Eaton
SP Jon Lieber
RP Armando Benitez
RP Octavio Dotel
RP Arthur Rhodes
DL A.J. Burnett

I really want to pick up SP Wilson Alvarez off the free agent list. In order to do that I have to drop one of these pitchers. Which one should I drop? I was thinking it should be Adam Eaton, who has struggled in his last couple starts, but am not sure. I might have chosen Pineiro before his last start in which he was starting to look like the pitcher he was last year. What are your thoughts?

[Chip R]

FWIW, I'd drop Lieber unless you don't think Burnett will do anything this year.

[EmtyRedsFan]

Lieber

[jmcclain19]

Mussina

Wins and ERA are overrated

[Red Leader]

I'm going to wait until after Eaton's start on Saturday. If he gets lit up to the toon of 6 ER in 1 1/3 IP again, he's gone. Lieber had a nice start today, only giving up a 3-R jack to Guillen. I love the fact that his WHIP is always under 1.00 because he doesn't walk anyone. Now, if only I could get my RP's to actually close out a ball game! Good God, between Dotel and Rhodes, I'm going to have a heart attack.

[listen up]

Hang on to Lieber and Mussina. Even if they aren't the best talent-wise, they'll still pick up a bunch of wins with the Yankees. I'd be looking at Eaton or Moyer.