My current pitching staff is:

Freddy Garcia
Jamie Moyer
Joel Pineiro
Adam Eaton
Mike Mussina
Jon Lieber
Armando Benitez
Octavio Dotel
Arthur Rhodes

Categories are: W, L, CG, SV, HR allowed, K, ERA, WHIP.

Someone in my league proposed the following trade:

I give: SP Adam Eaton and RP Arthur Rhodes

I get: SP Johan Santana and RP Jorge Julio.

I obviously could use the upgrade at SP and don't think the drop off at RP will hurt me too much with Benitez and Dotel. What do you think? Good trade or not, and why? What do you think about Rhodes and Julio in particular?