Kearns or Griffey

[JohnnyBench]

I just acquired Kearns in a trade. Now a guy in my league has offered me Griffey for Kearns.

Should I hold onto Kearns or go for Jr.?

[thrilljam]

I think I'd rather have Kearns, although both I feel will put up similar stats. I think Kearns is more apt to hit for a higher average, but both can put up similar power numbers (20-25 HR for Kearns, 25-30 for Jr, both could have around 80-85 RBI).

Do you need BA or HR?

[JohnnyBench]

I think I'd rather have Kearns, although both I feel will put up similar stats. I think Kearns is more apt to hit for a higher average, but both can put up similar power numbers (20-25 HR for Kearns, 25-30 for Jr, both could have around 80-85 RBI).

Do you need BA or HR?

BA is probably more of a need for me, so then I think you are saying I should stay with Kearns.

Thanks for your input, I appreciate it.

[Donk70]

I'd go for Kearns also. I think his power numbers will be a little better that Jr's.

[MuEconRedLeg]

Kearns. In the fantasy world, I simply cannot suggest Grif anymore.

[penantboundreds]

Griffey. Kearns is struggling and will soon be in a platoon when Pena comes off the DL. Griff looks healthy, offensively and defensively, he is getting his old swing back. Get Griff, he is raking and Kearns is about to be benched.

[KronoRed]

Gotta go with JR, Kearns is not getting enough playing time and with Miley I don't think that is going to change

[reds44]

Griffey

[kheidg-]

In my league I own both Kearns and Griffey. Kearns is currently on my bench while I have Griffey starting.

[Joseph]

I have to say Griffey here as well.

[BearcatDrew]

Griffey

[reds44]

Jr.

[Johnny Footstool]

One OF for another? I wouldn't make that trade. Get him to throw in something else if he wants Kearns so badly.

[JohnnyBench]

This original post was made at the start of the season, and now almost two months later, I think the answer is quite clear... I should have drafted Wily Mo!