I'm not positive but I would imagine it's the latter (the feature was on when you made the posts). By the way, I have no idea why that feature was on by default - I imagine it had to do with the UBB import.
Originally posted by Red Leader
I LOVE the new site, my questions is this: I went to my profile and turned the little e-mail notification default to 'no', but I am still getting them. Do these have to be unchecked every post you make at the bottom, or is it just that the feature was on when I made that post and it will send me one everytime there is a reply to that post. Please let me know when you get some time.