I don't think aging should qualify people for this survey unless they've paid some hack South American sawbones to pump their lips full of rendered hog fat. (Meg Ryan, I'm looking at you. And cringing.) We all get less hot as we get older.
I think we should only consider people as they were in their prime, or in a reasonably gray area of their prime. For instance, Sarah Jessica Parker isn't really in her prime anymore -- she peaked in "Honeymoon in Vegas," IMO. So if you didn't like her back then, you've got a legit entry in this survey. If you dug her back then, but don't like her now, it's kind of like saying, "Man, Lita Ford isn't all that hot."