I'm allowed two keepers for an 8-team league. I need to select two of these players:

Adam Dunn, David Wright and Jake Peavy

It's a 5x5 H2H league with one modification. We use OBP instead of AVG as an offensive category.

I'm leaning toward Dunn and Peavy but Wright has so much potential and plays a position that lacks quality depth.

Thoughts?