Do you think giving up 1B Prince Fielder and RP Chris Ray is too much to give up for 3B Scott Rolen or 3B Troy Glaus?
I'm trying to open up a roster spot for John Patterson and don't want to just simply drop someone. At the same time, I have 4 closers (Papelbon, Ryan, Gordon and Ray) and want to try and move one of them to open a roster spot for a SP.
If I move Fielder, I can move Youkilis to 1B and play Glaus or Rolen at 3B.
I chose to move Fielder instead of Youkilis because Youk helps in H, R, BB, OBP, and OPS more than Fielder although Fielder should do slightly better in RBI, HR, and SLG. I figured I could make up for those stats with the difference between Fielder and Glaus / Rolen.
What do you think? Too much to give up for either of them?