I'm on a thread roll.
M2 pointed to instruction as a possible reason as to why so many TB prospects seem to fail to reach their potential. Too often blame lies solely at the hands of the GM, and it should. But what is the deeper underlying issue? Is it instruction/development? Is it scouting?
Why have so many Reds prospects flamed out? Let's pick 5-10 Reds prospects from the last 10 years. This covers all regimes back to the Schott era. Include successes and failures, and compare and contrast them. Is there a consistent failing? Have any of those failings been addressed?