Turn Off Ads?
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 23

Thread: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

  1. #1
    Stat Wanker Hodiernus RedsManRick's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    Guelph, ON
    Posts
    16,039

    The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007
    What Can We Learn?

    In 1999, the Cardinals completed a mediocre decade that saw them win less than half their games (.488 winning %) and make the playoffs just once. Their longtime icon, Ozzie Smith, was on his way out, and they lacked any real identity or direction. The late 90ís saw a trade for Mark McGwire, who wowed fans and fellow ballplayers alike with record home run totals. Unfortunately for the Cards, he didnít do much for their playoff chances. The team was the definition of mediocre.

    However, times were changing. A confluence of events would quickly turn the Cardinals in to the NL team of the 2000s. From 2000 through 2006, the Cards averaged 94 wins, made the playoffs every year but once, and capped the run with a World Series victory. The road wasnít without itís bumps, including the tragic death of ace starter Darryl Kyle, the spectacular and untimely collapse of pitching phenom Rick Ankiel, and the underwhelming contributions of supposed all-world and oft-injured OF JD Drew.

    Itís now the end of the 2007 season and the run appears to have ended. The Redbirds have just locked up their first losing season of the decade, have one of the weakest minor league systems in baseball, only a few high ceiling youth on the major league roster, and their best on-field talent is quickly showing its age.

    That said, any organization would love to have that 7-year run capped with a Championship. Letís take a take a look at how it happened, what they did right, what went their way, and what lessons can be gleaned from their success. And letís also examine how it fell apart. Could it have been prevented?

    Sources:
    Baseball Reference (http://www.baseball-reference.com)
    Cotís Baseball Contracts (http://mlbcontracts.blogspot.com)
    USA Today (http://asp.usatoday.com/sports/baseb...aspx?year=yyyy)

    I apologize in advance for any factual errors. I've changed my approach a few times and had to go back over things. Also, apologies for the authoritative tone and haphazard organization observations section. This is really meant to spur discussion; not as my declaration of truth. So, on to the case study.


    October 1999 Ė The Setup
    Record: 75-86 (78-83 pythag)
    Runs Scored-Against: 809-838
    Playoffs: None
    Opening Day Payroll: $46,248,195 (15th MLB, 8th NL)
    Top 3 Draft picks: P Chance Caple (#30), P Nick Stocks (#36), 1B Chris Duncan (#46)

    Major Midseason Transactions:
    Aug 24th, 1999: Traded P Kent Mercker for P Mike Matthews and C David Benham (minors)

    Primary Contributors:
    C Marrero
    1B McGwire / Clark
    2B McEwing / Polanco
    SS Renteria
    3B Tatis
    LF Lankford
    CF Drew / Bragg
    RF Davis / Howard / McGee

    SP Bottenfield
    SP Oliver
    SP Jiminez
    SP Mercker
    SP Stephenson

    CL Bottalico
    RP Acevedo
    RP Aybar

    Summary: This was a team with a very shallow identity. For lack of a better term, they *****d McGwire and tried to put enough of a team around him to maintain respectability. McGwireís salary was over 20% of the payroll, which says a lot about the construction of the roster. Renteria, Drew, and Tatis represented a nice young offensive core, but the pitching staff was full of low ceiling youth and mediocre retread veterans and performed accordingly.


    2000 Ė Here Comes The Sun
    Record: 95-67 (91-71 pythag)
    Runs Scored-Allowed: 887-771
    Playoffs: Lost NLCS
    Opening Day Payroll: $63,900,023 (8th MLB, 5th NL)
    Top 3 Draft Picks: 2B Shaun Boyd (#13), P Blake Williams (#24), P Chris Narveson (#53)

    Major Offseason Transactions:
    Nov 16th, 1999: Acquired P Pat Hentgen and P Paul Spoljaric for C Alberto Castillo, P Matt DeWitt, and P Lance Pantier
    Nov 16th, 1999: Acquired P Darryl Kile, P Luther Hackman, and P Dave Veres for P Manny Aybar, IF Brent Bulter, P Rich Croushere, and P Jose Jiminez.
    Dec 15th, 1999: Signed C Mike Matheny; arb eligible
    Dec 20th, 1999: Acquired 2B Fernando Vina for P Juan Acevedo, C Eliezer Alfonso (minors), P Matt Parker (minors)
    March 23rd, 2000: Acquired OF Jim Edmonds for P Kent Bottenfield and 2B Adam Kennedy

    Major Midseason Transactions:
    July 31st: Acquired 1B Will Clark for Jose Leon.

    Primary Contributors:
    C Matheny
    1B McGwire / Clark
    2B Vina / Polanco
    SS Renteria
    3B Tatis / Paquette
    LF Lankford
    CF Edmonds
    RF Drew / Davis

    SP Kile
    SP Hentgen
    SP Stephenson
    SP Ankiel
    SP Benes

    CL Veres
    RP Morris
    RP James
    RP Slocumb
    RP Benes

    Summary: Show me the money. Jocketty went out and traded a lot of young talent for 4 all-stars in their primes who were approaching FA and coming off poor years. Did a great job of buying low and selling high to improve the level of talent at the major league level without completely emptying the cupboard. The 99/00 offseason was the big bang that set the Cardinal dynasty in motion.


    2001 Ė The Dawning of the Age of Albert Pujols
    Record: 93-69 (94-68 pythag)
    Runs Scored-Allowed: 814-684
    Playoffs: Lost NLDS
    Opening Day Payroll: $78,538,333 (9th MLB, 5th NL)
    Top 3 Draft Picks: P Justin Pope (#23), P Danny Haren (#72), SS Joe Mather (#104)

    Major Offseason Transactions:
    Dec 14th, 2000: P Pat Hentgen granted free agency.
    Dec 14th, 2000: Acquired P Dustin Hermanson and P Steve Kline for P Britt Reames and 3B Fernando Tatis.

    Major Midseason Transactions:
    Aug 2nd: Acquired P Woody Williams for OF Ray Lankford


    Primary Contributors:
    C Matheny / Marrero
    1B McGwire / Pujols
    2B Vina
    SS Renteria
    3B Polanco / Pujols
    LF Lankford / Pujols
    CF Edmonds
    RF Drew / Pujols

    SP Kile
    SP Morris
    SP Hermanson
    SP Benes / Smith
    SP Williams / Matthews

    CL Veres
    RP Matthews
    RP Kline
    RP Timlin
    RP Stechschulte

    Summary: Pujols was the 402nd pick of the 1999 draft and had a very solid debut in A ball, getting about 100 at bats in high A and AAA to end his first professional season. In 2000, he arrived a fully formed dynamo, able to keep the offense chugging along. The trade of Lankford for Woody Williams was a brilliant stroke which put Pujols in the everyday lineup while shoring up the starting rotation. Morris matured in to a starter, the deep bullpen gelled, and the team defense was excellent; Combined, run prevention improved significantly. It was very much a year of careful stewardship rather than bold action.


    2002 Ė OnceÖ TwiceÖ Three Times a Winner
    Record: 97-65 (95-67 pythag)
    Runs Scored-Allowed: 787-648
    Playoffs: Lost NLCS
    Opening Day Payroll: $74,660,875 (10th MLB, 6th NL)
    Top 3 Draft Picks: SS Calvin Hayes (#102), P John Boyer (#132), C Josh Bell (#162- DNS)

    Major Offseason Transactions:
    Dec 11th, 2001: Signed P Jason Isringhausen as a free agent; $27M/4yrs
    Dec 15th, 2001: Traded P Dustin Hermanson for 1B Dustin Brissom (minors), 1B Luis Garcia (minors), and OF Rick Asadoorian (minors)
    Dec 18th, 2001: Signed 1B Tino Martinez as a free agent; $21M/3yrs

    Major Midseason Transactions:
    June 22nd: P Darryl Kile passed away
    July 19th: Acquired P Steve Finley for 1B Luis Garcia and OF Coco Crisp
    July 29th: Acquired 3B Scott Rolen and P Doug Nickle for IF Placido Polanco, P Mike Timlin, and P Bud Smith

    Primary Contributors:
    C Matheny / Difelice
    1B Martinez
    2B Vina
    SS Renteria
    3B Polanco / Rolen / Pujols
    LF Pujols / Marrero
    CF Edmonds
    RF Drew / Marrero

    SP Morris
    SP Kile / Williams
    SP Benes / Smith
    SP Finley / Simontacchi
    SP Smith / Stevenson / Hackman

    CL Isringhausen
    RP Veres
    RP Timlin
    RP Kline
    RP Crudale

    Summary: Career seasons from a number of pitchers and great all around defense led to continued improvement in run prevention, despite a number of injuries and the tragic loss of Darryl Kile. The post-McGwire offense is in flux and scores fewer runs for the 2nd straight year. However, the midseason acquisition of Rolen cemented the middle of the lineup for years to come.


    2003 Ė Three Steps Forward, One Step Back
    Record: 85-77 (88-74 pythag)
    Runs Scored-Allowed: 876-796
    Playoffs: None
    Opening Day Payroll: $83,786,666 (8th MLB, 4th NL)
    Top 3 Draft Picks: C Daric Barton (#28), P Stuart Pomeranz (#65), P Dennis Dove (#95)

    Major Offseason Transactions:
    Nov 1st, 2002: Signed P Kiko Calero as a minor league free agent
    Nov 26th, 2002: Exercised option on P Woody Williams; $7.25M/1yr
    Dec 13th, 2002: Signed P Chris Carpenter as a free agent; $.5M/1yr w/ team option
    Dec 15th, 2002: Acquired P Brett Tomko for P Luther Hackman and P Mike Wodnicki (minors)

    Major Midseason Transactions:
    None

    Significant Contributors:
    C Matheny / Widger
    1B Martinez / Pujols
    2B Hart / Vina / Cairo
    SS Renteria
    3B Rolen
    LF Pujols
    CF Edmonds
    RF Drew / Perez / Palmeiro

    SP Morris
    SP Williams
    SP Tomko
    SP Stephenson / Hitchcock
    SP Simontacchi / Haren

    CL Isringhausen
    RP Kline
    RP Eldren
    RP Fassero

    Summary: The unfortunate death of Kile, the loss of Finley and Benes to FA, and the return to Earth for Woody Williams led to a big regression in run prevention. The bullpen, which had gone 5 deep the past few years, was suddenly quite mediocre behind the steady Isringhausen. The offense was superb, 2nd in the NL in runs scored, but it simply couldnít score enough to outpace the poor pitching.


    2004 Ė Far Away, So Close
    Record: 105-65 (100-62 pythag)
    Runs Scored-Allowed: 855-659
    Playoffs: Lost WS
    Opening Day Payroll: $83,228,333 (11th MLB, 7th NL)
    Top 3 Draft Picks: P Christopher Lambert (#19), 1B Michael Ferris (#60), P Eric Haberer (#90)

    Major Offseason Transactions:
    Nov 21st, 2003: Traded 1B Tino Martinez for P Evan Rust (minors) and 1B John-Paul Davis (minors)
    Dec 2nd, 2003: Re-signed P Chris Carpenter (2004 option not exercised), $2.5M/2yr
    Dec 13th, 2003: Traded OF JD Drew and C/OF Eli Marrero for P Jason Marquis, P Ray King, and P Adam Wainwright.
    Dec 18th, 2003: Signed P Jeff Suppan as free agent, $6M/2yr
    Dec 19th, 2003: Signed OF Reggie Sanders as free agent, $6M/2yr

    Major Midseason Transactions:
    Aug 6th: Acquired RF Larry Walker for Jason Burch, Luis Martinez, and Chris Narveson

    Significant Contributors:
    C Matheny / Molina
    1B Pujols
    2B Womack
    SS Renteria
    3B Rolen
    LF Lankford / Sanders / et. al.
    CF Edmonds
    RF Sanders / Walker

    SP Morris
    SP Williams
    SP Carpenter
    SP Marquis
    SP Suppan

    CL Isringhausen
    RP King
    RP Tavarez
    RP Kline
    RP Eldred

    Summary: Ladies and Gentlemen, THAT is a starting rotation. Those 5 starters combined for 154 games started and all but Williams had ERAs under league average. The most notable addition being Chris Carpenter, the once top prospect who spent 2004 rehabbing from Tommy John on the Cardinalís dime. The bullpen was spectacular, as new additions ROOGY Tavares and LOOGY King were used very effectively, easily offsetting the offensive downgrade from Drew to Sanders. The offense, with career years from Rolen and Edmonds, and with Pujols continuing to do his best Ted Williams impression, led the league with 855 runs scored.


    2005 Ė You Canít Always Get What You Want
    Record: 100-62 (98-64 pythag)
    Runs Scored-Allowed: 805-634
    Playoffs: Lost NLCS
    Opening Day Payroll: $92,106,833 (6th MLB, 3rd NL)
    Top 3 Draft Picks: OF Colby Rasums (#28), SS James Greene (#30), P Mark McCormick (#43)

    Major Offseason Transactions:
    Oct 29th, 2004: Edgar Renteria granted free agency
    Nov 4th, 2004: Woody Williams granted free agency
    Dec 7th, 2004: Re-signed P Matt Morris; $2.5M/1yr (earned $6.25M w/ incentives)
    Dec 18th, 2004: Acquired P Mark Mulder for P Danny Haren, P Kiko Calero, C Daric Barton (minors)
    Dec 23rd, 2004: Signed SS David Eckstein as free agent; $10.25M/3yrs

    Major Midseason Transactions:
    None

    Significant Contributors:
    C Molina / Diaz
    1B Pujols
    2B Grudzielanek
    SS Eckstein
    3B Nunez / Rolen
    LF Sanders / Rodriguez
    CF Edmonds
    RF Walker / Taguchi

    SP Carpenter
    SP Morris
    SP Mulder
    SP Marquis
    SP Suppan

    CL Isringhausen
    RP Tavarez
    RP Reyes
    RP Thompson
    RP King

    Summary: The offense was a testament to the power of OBP, as they had just 4 guys hit more than 10 HR. Pujols finally got his MVP over Bonds. Chris Carpenter apparently made it all the way back Ė and won a deserved Cy Young. New acquisition Mark Mulder replaced Woody Williams at little expense to the major league roster. The bullpen was excellent once again. The ERA of the various pitchers with mediocre stuff such as Suppan, Marquis, and Morris are a real testament to the value of a great defense. A healthy Scott Rolen might have been the difference between making the WS again, and being sent home by Carlos Beltóerr the Houston Astros.


    2006 Ė Iíd Rather be Lucky than Good
    Record: 83-78 (82-79 pythag)
    Runs Scored-Allowed: 781-672
    Playoffs: Won WS
    Opening Day Payroll: $88,891,371 (11th MLB, 7th NL)
    Top 3 Draft Picks: P Adam Ottavino (#30), P Christopher Perez (#42), P Thomas Furnish (#54)

    Offseason Transactions:
    Oct 28th, 2005: P Matt Morris granted free agency
    Nov 9th, 2005: OF Larry Walker granted free agency
    Dec 7th, 2005: Traded P Ray King for OF Larry Bigbie and 2B Aaron Miles
    Dec 22nd, 2005: Signed P Braden Looper as free agent; $13.5M/3yrs
    Jan 10th, 2006: Signed OF Juan Encarnacion as free agent; $15M/3yrs

    Midseason Transactions:
    July 5th: Acquired Jeff Weaver for Terry Evans
    Aug 18th: Signed Preston Wilson as free agent

    Significant Contributors:
    C Molina / Bennett
    1B Pujols
    2B Miles / Belliard / Luna
    SS Eckstein / Luna
    3B Rolen
    LF Taguchi / Duncan / et. al.
    CF Edmonds / Taguchi
    RF Encarnacion

    SP Carpenter
    SP Suppan
    SP Marquis
    SP Mulder / Reyes
    SP Ponson / Weaver

    CL Isringhausen
    RP Looper
    RP Hancock
    RP Wainwright
    RP Thompson

    Summary: 2006 was the awkward culmination of the Cardinals mini-dynasty. Make no mistake, this was a mediocre team with a few standout players dragging the rest of the roster to the playoffs in a pathetic NL Central. Injuries gave lots of at bats to backups who had no business getting them and Molina and Miles were sub-replacement level. Carpenter was superb yet again, but Jason Marquis fell off a cliff, Mark Mulder was ineffective before admitting injury, and none of the replacements were very good. The bullpen was merely ok, with rookie Adam Wainwright a bright spot. Jeff Weaver got confused and thought he was a good pitcher in October as they outlasted the Mets in the NLDS, out-pitched the Padres in the NLCS, and then the clearly superior Tigers just rolled over in the World Series.


    2007 Ė You Donít Know What Youíve Got ĎTil Itís Gone
    Record: 75-87* (70-92 pythag)
    Runs Scored-Allowed: 719-834*
    Playoffs: None
    Opening Day Payroll: $90,286,823 (11th MLB, 4th NL)
    Top 3 Draft Picks: SS Peter Kozma (#18), P Clayton Mortensen (#36), P David Kopp (#71)

    Offseason Transactions:
    Nov 11th, 2006: Signed IF Scott Spiezio as free agent; $4.5M/2yrs (team option for 2009)
    Nov 28th, 2006: Signed 2B Adam Kennedy as free agent; $10M/3yrs
    Nov 28th, 2006: Signed P Kip Wells as free agent; $4M/1yr
    Dec 4th, 2006: Signed P Chris Carpenter to extension; $63.5M/5yrs
    Jan 10th, 2007: Signed P Mark Mulder as free agent; $13M/2yrs (team option for 2009)

    Midseason Transactions:
    Jun 8th: Signed P Troy Percival as minor league free agent:
    Jun 22nd: Acquired P Mike Maroth for PTBNL
    Jul 31st: Acquired P Joel Pineiro for minor league PTBNL
    Aug 31st: Acquired IF/OF Russell Branyan for PTBNL

    Significant Contributors:
    C Molina / Bennett
    1B Pujols
    2B Kennedy / Miles
    SS Eckstein / Miles
    3B Rolen / Speizio
    LF Duncan / Ludwick / Taguchi
    CF Edmonds / Taguchi
    RF Encarnacion / Ankiel

    SP Wainwright
    SP Looper
    SP Wells
    SP Reyes / Pineiro
    SP Thompson / Wellemeyer / Maroth

    CL Isringhausen
    RP Franklin
    RP Springer
    FP Flores

    Summary: Blame the injury to Chris Carpenter if you want, but the real story is the absolute failure to replace lost talent. The 06/07 offseason was one of the most active, and yet a bunch of money was thrown to bit players. Why? Because 60% of the $90M payroll was invested in retaining Pujols, Rolen, Edmonds, Isringhausen, and Carpenter. Injuries continued to sap Rolen and Edmonds of playing time and effectiveness. Rick Ankielís miracle comeback is possibly already over. The minor leagues produced only a relatively ineffective Anthony Reyes and the midseason trades were for a bunch of castoffs rather than legitimate upgrades. They havenít scored runs and they havenít prevented them. It doesnít look promising for 2008 either. ~Fin


    Observations
    So, what can we learn? Well, Iíll let you draw your own conclusions. But I will make some observations, in no particular order.

    1. You need to get significant contributions from players making very little money. A winning team requires so much production, and production is valued so highly in the market, that no sub $100M payroll team can buy enough.
    2. If the players on your team making a lot of money arenít earning it, youíre in deep crap.
    3. Mediocre money spent on mediocre talent in free agency is money wasted. Unlike top level production, it can be obtained cheaply given prudent general management and good scouting. There's a new Jeff Keppinger every year.
    4. You have to either develop your talent or trade it for already developed talent. You cannot just let it rot. Itís like not getting your employers match on your 401k. You might not care now, but you will regret not maximizing your assets. Turn Kent Bottenfield into Jim Edmonds while somebody still believes he'll be more than just Kent Bottenfield someday.
    5. Beware significant investment in pitchers. It just comes down to injury. Few position players suffer season and career ending injuries. Many pitchers do and are more impacted by those injuries. Money should buy you less commitment, not more.
    6. Donít underestimate the value of not having sub replacement-level talent getting significant at bats. You can gain superstars worth of production by having real professional ballplayers at the bottom of your roster.
    7a. The value of good defense and offense in the same player cannot be emphasized enough. Those players are so rare and itís very easy to focus on one aspect of a playerís game and not give proper value to their failings in the overall evaluation of their worth. If Adam Dunn hit .250/.350/.475 and played average defense, would we consider him a potential cornerstone?
    7b. This is especially true up the middle. Quick, name all of the players up the middle who are average or better both offensive AND defensively. It shouldn't take long.
    8. Player development matters. Often, people pay a lot of attention to the draft and then put the responsibility of success solely on the player. The examples of players left underutilized or underdeveloped because of institution bias is incredibly long. The cost/benefit of good player development personnel decisions is the highest of any in the organization.
    9. Rescuing guys off the scrap heap can pay dividends, but donít build your retirement strategy around it. Jeff Weaver played a significant role in the 2006 WS win at minimal cost. Mark Mulder and Mike Maroth will provide virtually nothing for some significant money.
    10. If youíre going to make a move, make it matter. Don't go halfway with the hopes of getting the best of both worlds. Assuming the best rarely ends in good results. If you need everything to go your way to win, you need more things.
    11. Remember upside. Donít trade mediocre youth for mediocre vets. Do trade mediocre vets for mediocre youth. You might be underestimating your youth. Youíre likely overestimate the vets. If another organization has a history of exploiting these types of deals, be very very careful. They are probably better than you at evaluating talent.
    12. Talent is the real currency of baseball, not money. Talent is finite, money (essentially) isnít. If you have talent, you can get money. You can get money from a variety of places. But no matter how much money you have, talent is quite limited. There is only 1 Albert Pujols. In other words, donít "cash in" talent with the assumption you can buy it back later. If you can ever afford to, hoard talent.
    13. If you feel you have the opportunity to succeed in the short term, identify your needs and fill them. You never know when you'll get another chance. Just donít forget the ďdonít do it halfwayĒ rule.
    Games are won on run differential -- scoring more than your opponent. Runs are runs, scored or prevented they all count the same. Worry about scoring more and allowing fewer, not which positions contribute to which side of the equation or how "consistent" you are at your current level of performance.

  2. Turn Off Ads?
  3. #2
    Posting in Dynarama M2's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2000
    Location
    Boston
    Posts
    28,173

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    Nice post RMR.
    Baseball isn't a magic trick ... it doesn't get spoiled if you figure out how it works. - gonelong

    I'm witchcrafting everybody.

  4. #3
    Rally Onion! Chip R's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2000
    Location
    Cincinnati, OH
    Posts
    34,450

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    It should read "The St. Louis Cardinals 1999-2007 - The Empire Built on Steroids."

    Fine article, though.
    The Rally Onion wants 150 fans before Opening Day.

    http://www.facebook.com/pages/Rally-...24872650873160

  5. #4
    Member Crosley68's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2000
    Location
    West Virginia
    Posts
    958

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    Very nice. I particularly buy into #12.
    Let's play two!!!

  6. #5
    Churlish Johnny Footstool's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2001
    Location
    Olathe, KS
    Posts
    13,794

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    12. Talent is the real currency of baseball, not money. Talent is finite, money (essentially) isn’t. If you have talent, you can get money. You can get money from a variety of places. But no matter how much money you have, talent is quite limited. There is only 1 Albert Pujols. In other words, don’t "cash in" talent with the assumption you can buy it back later. If you can ever afford to, hoard talent.
    Exactly right. Money is easy to come by in MLB; talent is not.

    New acquisition Mark Mulder replaced Woody Williams at little expense to the major league roster.
    This is one of the few statements I'd have to dispute. Kiko Calero was excellent in the Cards' bullpen in 2003 and 2004, and Haren's decent 2004 showed he was ready to break out in 2005. And both were making near league minimum. Even if you disregard the performances of all parties in 2005, those two were valuable parts of the Cards' roster at the time of the trade.
    Last edited by Johnny Footstool; 09-24-2007 at 12:17 PM.
    "I prefer books and movies where the conflict isn't of the extreme cannibal apocalypse variety I guess." Redsfaithful

  7. #6
    Stat Wanker Hodiernus RedsManRick's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    Guelph, ON
    Posts
    16,039

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    Quote Originally Posted by Johnny Footstool View Post
    This is one of the few statements I'd have to dispute. Kiko Calero was excellent in the Cards' bullpen in 2003 and 2004, and Haren's decent 2004 showed he was ready to break out in 2005. And both were making near league minimum. Even if you disregard the performances of all parties in 2005, those two were valuable parts of the Cards' roster at the time of the trade.
    As I typed it, I realize that their could be disagreement. But Calero pitched fewer than 50 IP in 2004 and Haren, unfortunately wasn't going to crack the Cardinal rotation in 2005. I was referencing an expected contribution rather than what they really could have done had the trade not been made.

    It's not that Calero and Haren weren't valuable to the Cardinals. It's that their expected contributions for 2005 were not significant. While I never come out and say it explicitly, the Mulder trade was absolutely one of the major causes of the downfall.

    Whereas Jocketty bought low on Darryl Kile due to his poor year in Colorado, and added a key starter without giving up too much, he paid full price on Mulder. And whereas Kile rebounded wonderfully, with the cause of his poor year removed, Mulder's poor year was not a fluke.

    Furthermore, the acquisition of Kile and Edmonds was predicated on a payroll expansion which would allow for retaining their services without financial impact to the current set of commitments. When Mulder was acquired, payroll was already maxed out. Jocketty lost sight of the necessity to get major contributions from pre-arb players, as failure of any paid-for talent leaves little wiggle room for improvement.

    Bottom line, Jocketty overvalued Mulder, and undervalued Haren. Haren could've approximated Mulder's contributions much more cheaply and for years to come. Jocketty was playing to a window, which in general isn't a bad idea. The problem was in the choice of player he acquired.

    He also gave up on Haren at precisely the wrong moment. The only purpose of trading him at that point in time is if you think he's not going to make it, that his value has peaked, and that he better served the organization by converting his value into a more efficient use of the roster spot on a greater talent. It was a move about increasing the talent to roster spot ratio, but it failed on it's premise. Instead, St Louis simply got a higher risk, more expensive version of Haren, lost a solid reliever, and gave away a top hitting prospect. A net talent loss for the organization for which they are still paying.
    Games are won on run differential -- scoring more than your opponent. Runs are runs, scored or prevented they all count the same. Worry about scoring more and allowing fewer, not which positions contribute to which side of the equation or how "consistent" you are at your current level of performance.

  8. #7
    Pitching is the thing WVRedsFan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2000
    Location
    Rainelle, WV
    Posts
    8,148

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    Quote Originally Posted by Crosley68 View Post
    Very nice. I particularly buy into #12.
    I totally agree. That is my main gripe against the Reds' front office in this regard. We ussually sift through the garbage can to find talent. That's risky. It sometimes works and sometimes doesn't as we've seen in the players we have obtained over the last two years.

    Some garbage is hidden treasure. Some garbage is garbage and it's a real gamble to operate like that.

  9. #8
    Danger is my business! oneupper's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Location
    Back in Florida
    Posts
    8,157

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    I like number 6. Don't underestimate how much crappy players (Juan Castro...I'm talking to you) can hurt you.
    "A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky, dangerous animals and you know it."

    http://dalmady.blogspot.com

  10. #9
    Member OnBaseMachine's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Posts
    34,844

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    Quote Originally Posted by Chip R View Post
    It should read "The St. Louis Cardinals 1999-2007 - The Empire Built on Steroids."

    Fine article, though.

  11. #10
    Member Spitball's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2000
    Posts
    5,626

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    Very interesting read!
    "I am your child from the future. I'm sorry I didn't tell you this earlier." - Dylan Easton

  12. #11
    The Big Dog mth123's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Posts
    14,843

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    Good stuff RMR.
    "All I can tell them is pick a good one and sock it." --BABE RUTH

    Having better players makes "the right time" or "the big hit" happen a lot more often. PLUS PLUS

  13. #12
    Big Red Machine RedsBaron's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2000
    Location
    Out Wayne
    Posts
    22,850

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    Good post. I enjoyed it, and you made good points.
    "Hey...Dad. Wanna Have A Catch?" Kevin Costner in "Field Of Dreams."

  14. #13
    Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2001
    Posts
    13,792

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    Enjoyed the post. Thanks for the work putting it together.

    The lesson I see is that you need to get talent from a number of sources -- but when the opportunity presents itself you have to be willing to spend for big time talent. McGwire, Rolen, Walker, Edmonds, Kile, Mulder, Carpenter -- the Cards were willing to spend to acquire these guys because the Cards view themselves as a top major league franchise competing with other top teams. Not every move worked, but generally these major acquisitions helped the Cards become a winner.

    Other than Griffey (special situation due to home town connection) and arguably Milton, I can't remember the Reds going after big name, top talent from other teams.

    Drafting well is great, finding good bargains is great, but at some point you have to go for it. Patching together kids and cheap free agents is not a winning plan.

    I think on RedsZone we are sometimes too understanding of the Reds' small market approach. Ultimately, there are a limited number of great baseball players and if you don't have some of them it's very hard to win. A few are available every year. They cost money but somebody goes out and gets them and those teams generally win.
    Last edited by Kc61; 09-24-2007 at 10:14 PM.

  15. #14
    SERP Emeritus paintmered's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2001
    Location
    Cbus
    Posts
    7,048

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    Quote Originally Posted by Crosley68 View Post
    Very nice. I particularly buy into #12.
    If there is one bit of advice Krivsky needs to hear, that's it.

    Wonderful stuff, RMR.

    (Mods, can you copy this to the archives?)
    Last edited by paintmered; 09-24-2007 at 10:17 PM.
    What if this wasn't a rhetorical question?

    All models are wrong. Some of them are useful.

  16. #15
    Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2002
    Location
    Calgary, Alberta, aka, the most prosperous city in the world.
    Posts
    10,681

    Re: The St. Louis Cardinals: 1999-2007

    Quote Originally Posted by RedsManRick View Post
    As I typed it, I realize that their could be disagreement. But Calero pitched fewer than 50 IP in 2004 and Haren, unfortunately wasn't going to crack the Cardinal rotation in 2005.

    If the Cards didn't have Mulder in 2005, Haren would have been in the rotation.


Turn Off Ads?

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Board Moderators may, at their discretion and judgment, delete and/or edit any messages that violate any of the following guidelines: 1. Explicit references to alleged illegal or unlawful acts. 2. Graphic sexual descriptions. 3. Racial or ethnic slurs. 4. Use of edgy language (including masked profanity). 5. Direct personal attacks, flames, fights, trolling, baiting, name-calling, general nuisance, excessive player criticism or anything along those lines. 6. Posting spam. 7. Each person may have only one user account. It is fine to be critical here - that's what this board is for. But let's not beat a subject or a player to death, please.

Thank you, and most importantly, enjoy yourselves!


RedsZone.com is a privately owned website and is not affiliated with the Cincinnati Reds or Major League Baseball


Contact us: Boss | GIK | BCubb2003 | dabvu2498 | Gallen5862 | LexRedsFan | Plus Plus | RedlegJake | redsfan1995 | The Operator | Tommyjohn25