OK, I'm in a 10 team 3 player keeper league. I couldn't ask for 3 better keepers, I have ARod, Reyes, and Utley. I won this league last year so my 1st non keeper picks will come at #40 and #41.

My question is, what would be your strategy as far as these 2 picks? I am almost certain that the only 2 pitchers that will be kept are Johan and Peavy. Would you take 2 offensive players with these picks and then most likely dominate nearly every offensive category, or would you take 2 starters here and then have the beginning of a very balanced team? Of course I could always take my #1 pitcher and the best available OF or 1B as well.