Lineupology?
BY JOHN ERARDI | ENQUIRER STAFF WRITER
E-mail thisE-mail | Printer-FriendlyPrint | digg us!
We asked our sabermetricians to take a look at the Reds' batting order to see what the numbers showed regarding who should bat where.
We asked for two batting orders, one vs. right-handed pitchers and one vs. left-handed pitchers, keeping in mind that as a whole, left-handed batters hit right-handed pitchers best, and vice versa.
BATTING ORDER VS. RHP
No. Player Bats Pos.
1. Joey Votto L 1B
2. Adam Dunn L LF
3. Edwin Encarnacion R 3B
4. Jay Bruce L CF
5. Ken Griffey Jr. L RF
6. Brandon Phillips R 2B
7. Javier Valentin S C
8. Jeff Keppinger R SS
9. Pitcher
Slot-by-slot explanation
1. Votto: He might strike out more than some would like, but he does the most important thing for a leadoff hitter (or any hitter) - he gets on base (.360-.408 on-base percentage at every pro level).
2. Dunn: He's a non-traditional No. 2 hitter, but batting here leverages his strengths of getting on base and helps avoid double plays (a problem with many more traditional "contact" two-hole hitters). In addition, hitting here gives him more at-bats. Each spot in the batting order is worth around 15 more plate appearances over a full year than the spot after it.
3. Encarnacion: He's better than fans think, and he's at an age (25) when improvement is likely. Plus he would break up the left-handed hitters.
4. Bruce: Projected to be a tremendous hitter but just 20 years old with only 187 Triple-A at-bats, this rookie is clearly better than any combination of Ryan Freel/Norris Hopper/Corey Patterson. If the Reds are trying to win in 2008, the projected numbers show Bruce should be the everyday center fielder. His career minor-league slugging percentages are .542 in Single-A, .652 in Double-A and .567 in Triple-A and he has hit better than .300 at every level.
5. Griffey - He takes one for the team hitting fifth, protects the kid and gets a run at a ring.
6. Phillips: Putting the 30-30 man in the six-hole? Are the sabermetricians kidding? No. Phillips looks every part the real deal, but the numbers indicate he needs to improve at getting on base. His on-base average is low for somebody of his overall ability.
Luckhaupt's explanation: "The reason that Phillips is batting sixth against right-handers is that every batter in front of him hits right-handers much better. Votto, Dunn, Bruce and Griffey are all lefties who have hit righties very well in the past. The lowest OPS (on-base percentage plus slugging percentage) that Baseball Prospectus predicts for any of the four against righties is Griffey at .878. That's Murderer's Row production.
"Another good reason is that Phillips' speed allows for more manufacturing of runs in the lower half of the lineup, something that isn't as necessary in the top half when you've got that kind of firepower," Luckhaupt said.
7. Jeff Keppinger: He projects as a very good hitter with one of the better on-base averages on the team. You could bat him eighth and give the Reds a "second leadoff" hitter, but he also could hit first or second in the lineup.
8. Javier Valentin: The sabermetricians always have felt that Valentin should stop batting right-handed and bat only lefty. He has had a lot of success against right-handed pitchers in his career, but last season he didn't.
BATTING ORDER VS. LHP
No. Player Bats Pos.
1. Keppinger R 1B
2. Dunn L LF
3. Phillips R 2B
4. Bruce L CF
5. Encarnacion R 3B
6. Griffey L RF
7. David Ross R C
8. Alex Gonzalez R SS
9. Pitcher
Slot-by-slot explanation
1. Keppinger: He would play first base and leadoff because Votto doesn't hit lefties well.
2. Dunn: He is not as good a hitter vs. lefties as he is against righties, but he's decent and still gets on base.
3. Phillips: Hits lefties better than Encarnacion.
4. Bruce: Same reasoning as vs. RHP.
5. Encarnacion: As a right-handed hitter, he hits lefties better than Griffey.
6. Griffey: He used to be a good hitter against lefties, but in three of the last four years he has dropped off.
7. David Ross: His bad on-base average keeps him down here.
8. Alex Gonzalez: See Ross comments. (Note: Gonzalez is injured.)
THE POINT OF ALL THIS
The only real opportunities for offensive improvement - besides wishing Dunn hits 50 homers or Phillips goes 40/40 or Norris Hopper hits .340 - is making Bruce the center fielder, getting Keppinger into the lineup full time and playing Votto over Scott Hatteberg.
http://news.enquirer.com/apps/pbcs.d...PT04/803090384