IMO shortstop, catcher & centerfield are 'defense first' positions.
Find a guy who can play A or B grade defense at these spots and get your offense from the other five positions.
OPS (all gold glove winners):
Erstad .702 2002
Vizquel .691 2005, .749 2006
Izturis .710 2004
Ausmus .593 2006, .675 2002, .625 2001
These are just examples. I have been thinking recently about a guy like Patterson or Janish in AAA. These guys can really play defense but have weak sticks. For truly gold glove defense ( ie top 1-2 in NL ) at SS,CF & C what OPS are you willing to accept?