Only an Idiot would have accepted Edinson Volquez straight up for Dunn last offseason. Who would have known he would be 9-1 In his starts this year?
Hamilton was Worth Volquez, yeah... But look what Hamilton is doing... Those players both had Potential to be Stars... And they are going at it like that...
Your comparison is silly really...
The Rangers were not going to come up with Volquez and his 3-11 record and go...
"Ok Cincinnati, we want Adam Dunn and his 40 Homers for this unproven guy with a 3-11 record"