i voted for the last one but if this is just for fun...
i'd be shocked, a little concerned (cuz of how much $ that would take), but i'd definitely be excited and i bet most reds fans would feel the same way (shocked and excited at least). i think the 'experts' would expect us to have at least 15+ more wins and contend for a playoff spot.
whether suzuki is the very best leadoff hitter could be debated (no power/doesn't walk much) but he's definitely one of the very best, solid defensively and really not THAT old. that said, if i could have
any leadoff hitter i'd probably take jose reyes over him since he'd also solve our annual problem at shortstop.
i'd also take a 100% healthy pujols over manny any day (again if i could have anyone). no less of a hitter and possibly better, can steal a base and turn a single into a double occasionally instead of a double into a single, younger, better defensively, and less of a headcase. i'd even take ordonez over manny. i know manny is a 1st ballot hall of famer and has been incredible in LA but it's kinda funny how he does that now before he becomes a FA. it wasn't long ago people thought manny was on the decline. (can ya tell i'm not his #1 fan?
)
but people would start to talk about a cincy team in the playoffs again that's for sure and wouldn't that be a nice change.