Save the debate about whether or not they need a RH bat. Walt clearly believes they do. He wants a RH bat for the middle of the order. It would seem that player would need to play either LF or CF (unlikely, but let's not eliminate the idea), or, conceivably, SS or third base (if they move Encarnacion to LF, for example).
So ... who will it be? We know the usual suspects:
Who else? Guys I'm thinking about:
Xavier Nady (unfortunately, the Yanks probably don't want anything we'd be willing to offer)
Melvin Mora (not sure if he's available, but would be an interesting option)
Others have mentioned Alex Rios. Is he available?
They could roll the dice with Jeff Francouer.
So let's find the guy.