Speed helping increase a players value has been discussed especially regarding Mr. Taveras. The argument is that his speed offsets his low OBP.
Below you will find the top 20 NL base stealers (by total stolen bases). So can we all agree that these guys are generally "fast" dudes?
So the question is, can speed add to a players value, especially if they have a hard time getting on base with regularity?
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This first group includes some of the top base stealers (by definition fast guys) in NL MLB. Something interesting is happening here, however. Despite all their speed their value compared to a replacement (read: scrub) player is either negligible or below. In other words, they aren't scoring as many runs as a scrub player would.Code:YEAR NAME PA EqA OBP OUTR R VORP SB SB% 2008 Willy Taveras 538 .238 .308 0.67658 64 1.8 68 90.7% 2008 Michael Bourn 514 .222 .288 0.70623 57 -11.5 41 80.4% 2008 Juan Pierre 406 .246 .327 0.66749 44 1.7 40 76.9% 2008 Cesar Izturis 454 .234 .319 0.6674 50 2.6 24 80.0%
Yes, scoring runs is dependent on your team-mates. But 3 of the four players come from some fairly good teams. So with names like Pujols, Ankiel, Holliday, Kemp and Rameriz behind you, the run totals should be high.
Runs: The total runs scored by this group are the lowest of the bunch and 64 runs was the high score. 53 runs was the average.
EqA: Offensive production, including base-running, below average (.260) for the entire group.
VORP: Runs scored are at or below replacement level.
OBP: All below average
Out Rates: All above 65%
Code:YEAR NAME PA EqA OBP OUTR R VORP SB SB% 2008 Jose Reyes 763 .294 .358 0.63172 113 62.9 56 78.9% 2008 Jimmy Rollins 625 .282 .349 0.6416 76 44.3 47 94.0% 2008 Shane Victorino 627 .277 .352 0.63317 102 34.2 36 76.6% 2008 Hanley Ramirez 693 .320 .400 0.5873 125 78.6 35 74.5% 2008 Matt Kemp 657 .279 .340 0.64384 93 32.8 35 76.1% 2008 Matt Holliday 623 .316 .409 0.57785 107 61.7 28 93.3% 2008 Carlos Beltran 706 .308 .376 0.61756 116 57.6 25 89.3% 2008 Randy Winn 667 .283 .363 0.62219 84 30.2 25 92.6% 2008 L Milledge 587 .257 .330 0.66269 65 13.2 24 72.7% 2008 Nate Mclouth 685 .300 .356 0.63796 113 49.4 23 88.5% 2008 B Phillips 609 .257 .312 0.66831 80 15.4 23 69.7% 2008 Corey Hart 657 .260 .300 0.67884 76 11.1 23 76.7% 2008 Ryan Theriot 661 .263 .387 0.60666 85 27.1 22 62.9% 2008 Fred Lewis 521 .276 .351 0.6334 81 20.2 21 75.0% 2008 Jayson Werth 482 .297 .363 0.62241 73 31.3 20 95.2% 2008 Kazuo Matsui 422 .277 .354 0.64455 58 21.6 20 80.0%
This second group of the top 20 NL base stealers shows us something very interesting:
Runs: Total runs are generally very high, ranging from 125 to 58. The average is 90.
EqA: All above average except 2 (Milledge and BPhill)
VORP: Runs scored relative to a scrub are all double digits
OBP: All average or above except 3 (Millledge, Bhill and Corey Hart)
Out Rates: All below 65% except 2 (Milledge and BPhill)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
It would appear that speed has done nothing to help the four guys grouped above. It's also worthy of note that they all have sub-par OBP, EqA and above average out rates. So despite having some of the higher stolen base percentages and gaudy stolen base totals these guys clearly had no value last year.
If they could offset their weaknesses by "reeking havoc" on the base paths why doesn't it show up in their numbers? They all scored minimal run totals and are replacement level VORP. And the differences are stark compared to their mates in the second group.
Meanwhile, the guys who have above average OBP, EQA and below average out rates mostly scored more runs (significantly more) and have higher VORP.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Speed is a great thing, especially since catchers have generally become weaker at throwing out base runners. I'm not knocking speed at all.
But speed has to be used wisely to be effective.
More importantly, the player has to have a chance to use his speed. The more chances the player has to use their speed, the more he can use his speed to help his team.
I think these numbers pretty clearly demonstrate that a player can not make up for his inability to get on base by being fast. A more accurate statement is that a player who gets on base regularly can further increase his value by being fast.