What Reds players or decisions of the last 20 years have you been completely wrong about? Who did you think was destined for stardom but completely crapped the bed? Who did you think should have been sent out to pasture, yet ended up eclipsing all possible expectations?
I liked the Corey Patterson signing last year (duck, cover)
I was looking forward to Brandon Claussen anchoring the staff for the next decade.
I was also quite upset when Jeff Treadway was traded to Atlanta.
I'll have a few more later...anyone else care to share?