Which list would you choose?

From BA's list this years 11-20:
11. Daryl Thompson
12. Chris Dickerson
13. Jordan Smith
14. Josh Roenicke
15. Zach Stewart
16. Ryan Hanigan
17. Ramon Ramirez
18. Matt Maloney
19. Zach Cozart
20. Juan Carlos Sulbaran

or 2004 1-10:
1. Ryan Wagner
2. Edwin Encarnacion
3. Brandon Claussen,
4. Dustin Moseley
5. Joey Votto
6. Phil Dumatrait
7. Stephen Smitherman
8. Tyler Pelland
9. Chris Gruler
10. Ty Howington
When answering, try to do so by thinking of the 2004 group as if it is 2004, in that you have no clue how they managed since then, just what you thought of them as prospects.