Originally Posted by
TheNext44
Whenever I see people get excited over spring stats, I like to tell this story:
In 1996, a friend of mine got a chance to interview Jim Bowden down in spring training. I was down there with him so he invited me to tag along. We met Bowden in his spring training office in Plant City. It was pretty cool, as right behind him was the organizational depth chart. It literally ranked every player in the Reds organization according to position. It was huge.
Also, Ray Knight, the manager that year, was just finishing up his daily meeting with Bowden when we got there. There were going over the roster, and I got to hear them talk about two players, Eric Owens and Jeff Shaw.
The first thing that I noticed was that they didn't use or talk about stats at all. They worked from sheets that broke down every AB or batter faced for each player, pitch by pitch. These sheets had notes on key pitches in each AB. It was these notes that they talked about most.
For Owens, they focused on one AB, when he was facing a hard throwing reliever. (They never said his name, just said that this guy threw mid 90's). They were worried about Owens being able to get around the high heat. In this AB, Owens K'd, but on a 2-2 pitch he turned on the guy's fastball high and tight, and drove it foul, but with home run distance. That one swing did it for them. Owens was now a favorite to make the team.
For Shaw, Knight was trying to convince Bowden that he had set up or closer stuff. He liked that he attacked hitters and was not afraid to pitch inside. He showed Bowden sheet after sheet of him doing that. He also showed him that Shaw bounced back well after getting lit up. Again, no numbers were discussed.
The point is that while all we have to go on is stats, and seeing the few games that we do, the team has access to much, much more detailed data. This enables them to ignore stats, and make much more well informed decisions that we can. This probably is why Ward was let go so early. They probably saw something they didn't like that he could not fix.
Anyway, after that experience (which was one of the most awesome ones of my life), I never second guess a team's roster decisions or worry about spring stats.