55 years ago (1954), a 5-4 loss at the Polo Grounds in Upper Manhattan vs. the Giants.
Cincinnati
Bobby Adams 3b
Roy McMillan ss
Gus Bell cf
Ted Kluszewski 1b
Jim Greengrass lf
Johnny Temple 2b
Wally Post rf
Ed Bailey c
Fred Baczewski p
New York Giants
Davey Williams 2b
Alvin Dark ss
Hank Thompson 3b
Monte Irvin lf
Willie Mays cf
Don Mueller rf
Whitey Lockman 1b
Ray Katt c
Ruben Gomez p
WP: Marv Grissom (2-0)
LP: Fred Baczewski (2-2)
HR: CIN - Ted Kluszewski (10). NY - Whitey Lockman (4), Willie Mays (6).